Part of what makes a particular piece of writing stand out, is the author's ability to create memorable characters.
Most writers have fun playing around with naughty characters. Others seek to romance the reader with heroes so gallant, they wish said heroes could materialise and sweep them off their feet. Fairy stories on the other hand, are notorious for getting criminal characters misclassified as heroes (as discussed in the linked article).
What I'd like to discuss today is the portrayal of a number of parents in traditional fairy tales. While reading the following stories to my children, I wonder over and over again, why the parents failed to do something about their children's dilemmas.
Here's the countdown to my worst fairy tale parents.
Cinderella's dad
After his wife's death, Cinderella's dad hooked up with an awful woman who had 2 spoilt brats of her own. The new mother-figure he chose for his impressionable daughter, still traumatised from her mother's death, was a woman who knew nothing about raising children.
After all, she'd let her own two run riot. In an age where a woman's place was doing house work and bringing up kids, her daughters couldn't even tie their own shoe laces let alone style their own hair. He gave this stranger power over his household and free rein to physically and mentally abuse his own child. Call the social services. Mr. Cinderella is one stroke short of a full midnight!
Rapunzel's parents
They agreed to give up their own child to a woman they knew dabbled in black arts. Whatever happened to protecting your child at all cost? For a silly little pregnancy craving, a little girl was 'sold' to spend the rest of her life in a tower all by herself. There's no fairness in that. Parents who put up less than a fight for their beautiful baby do not deserve a strand of pity.
Hanzel and Gretel's dad
Here's another man who made bad personal choices and caused his children to suffer because of it. His wife died, leaving him with two kids to look after on his own. It was obviously a difficult time for him. Not only did he lose his wife, but he hadn't work in such a long time, it was getting difficult to feed his own family. His new wife came up with the bizarre solution to the hardship problem which solely involved straying the kids. In our day and age, people who stray animals are classed as criminals. As the story goes, it didn't take him long to be convinced that 'losing' the kids in the woods was a pretty good idea.
In the end, this lazy loser-dad succeeded with his dirty deed, causing no end of trouble for the youngsters. It was only through Gretel's strong will and quick wit that they did not also lose their lives. Did their father take them back once they returned home with gold and other treasures? You bet he did.
Snow White's step-mother
Do you see a common trend? Fathers in fairy tales don't seem to take any responsibility for their kids. Here is one who remarried a narcissist so involved in herself that she was prepared to kill her young step-daughter merely for being prettier. Where was the father in all this and why didn't he put a stop to the crazy campaign? This evil step-mother hitched up a terrible plan of poison, cruelty, abandonment and attempted murder. Any mother mirroring this step-mother's example of child abuse and neglect is bound for prison in my book.
Jack's (from the beanstalk) mother
Here is a mother the social services would love to get their giant, collective hands on. She encourages her son to first of all steal (repeatedly) someone else's treasures they'd worked hard to build up. If that wasn't enough, when the big guy came calling to retrieve his possessions - and he had every right to - she assisted her son in murdering him!
We can't do anything about these parents or the way they've behaved with their kids. After all, they're merely fictional people. But how do we write parents' characters these days? Are they people with faults, or are they literary errors (like the ones we've just looked at) wearing an illusion of human nature?
No comments:
Post a Comment